AABA How Jersey shot itself in the foot: an analysis of the implications of the Trusts (35 pages)
revealed: how jersey woos tax avoiders
Appendix 5 – Observer article of 17 September 2006 regarding
appendices 2 and 3
Revealed: how Jersey woos tax avoiders
Sunday September 17, 2006
Internal correspondence between the highest-ranking tax officials in Jersey,
seen by The Observer, expose for the first time how the tax haven is
actively helping the world's super-rich to avoid tax.
A series of emails, dated from last week, and whose participants include
Jersey's head of tax and its Treasury minister, reveal how trust reform will
'allow Jersey to compete more effectively for international work, where
wealthy families will often wish to place assets in a trust structure and yet
retain certain control over the management of the trust assets'.
In the emails, the Jersey Treasury minister, Paul de Gruchy, writes to his
colleagues: 'The tax burden, as with inheritance tax in the UK, will be borne
by those who are moderately wealthy but not so wealthy as to be able to
afford to place significant assets out of reach for a reasonable period of
When shown the emails, Richard Murphy of the Tax Justice Network, a
campaign group highlighting tax evasion, said: 'This proves that Jersey is
rotten to the core. We now have evidence that its government knowingly
facilitates tax evasion by creating legislation that allows it to happen. The
government of Jersey has allowed the creation of sham trusts. Trustees are
UK-trained and UK-regulated solicitors and accountants. The UK's
professional bodies should make it clear that this is unacceptable. It's clear
that the Jersey government's aim is to help the rich evade the tax that they
should be paying to other governments, including the UK's.'
Vince Cable, the Lib Dem Treasury spokesman, said: 'The UK government
should blow the whistle and not sanction this.' The world's richest
individuals have placed $11.5 trillion of assets in offshore havens.
Chancellor Gordon Brown has come under attack this month for failing to
clamp down on havens.
Malcolm Campbell, Jersey controller of income tax, said: 'There's nothing
novel in the proposed changes, which can also be found in the trust laws of
other jurisdictions such as New Zealand and Delaware plus a number of
other US States. Nor do they do anything to make tax avoidance or evasion
more likely than under the present statute.'
Guardian Unlimited © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2006